Fact Check: Video of shoe being hurled at minister Mansukh Mandaviya is not recent

NewsMeter found that the video shows shoes hurled at Mansukh Mandaviya but from 2017.

By Md Mahfooz Alam  Published on  12 April 2024 12:08 PM GMT
Fact Check: Video of shoe being hurled at minister Mansukh Mandaviya is not recent

Screengrabs of the viral video. (Source: X/@INCBANSAL)

Claim: The video shows a shoe thrown at BJP leader and Union minister Mansukh Mandaviya ahead of the Lok Sabha election.
Fact: The video shows shoes hurled at Mansukh Mandaviya but from 2017. The incident happened during a public function in Vallabhipur town in Gujaratā€™s Bhavnagar district.

Hyderabad: As the election campaign for the 2024 Lok Sabha elections is heating up, a video showing a man hurling a shoe at a leader delivering a speech on the stage during a public meeting is viral on social media with the claim that it shows a shoe being thrown at BJP leader and Union minister Mansukh Mandaviya.

ā€œUnion Minister Mansukh Mandaviya in Gujaratā€™s Porbandar welcomed with shoes (translated from Hindi),ā€ wrote an X user who shared the video. (Archive)

(Source: X/@INCBANSAL)

Fact Check

NewsMeter found that the video shows shoes hurled at Mansukh Mandaviya but from 2017.

We ran a relevant keyword search and found a video report by News 24 published on May 29, 2017, titled ā€˜Shoe hurled at Union Minister Mansukh Mandaviya in Gujarat.ā€™

According to the channel, the incident happened in Gujaratā€™s Bhavnagar. It also mentioned that the person who hurled shoes at the Union minister reportedly belonged to the group demanding Patidarā€™s community reservation.


A Hindustan Times report of May 28, 2017, said an activist of Hardik Patel-led Patidar Anamat Andolan Samiti hurled a shoe at Mandaviya during a public function in Vallabhipur town in Gujaratā€™s Bhavnagar district. It also reported that the local police arrested the 20-year-old college student Bhavesh Sonani following the incident.

The Times of India and NDTV also reported the incident with the same details.

According to a report by The Economics Times of April 8, the Gujarat BJP has filed a complaint with the poll authorities seeking action against those circulating the old video.

Hence, we conclude amid the election season, an old video of a shoe hurled at Union minister Mansukh Mandaviya is being shared as recent.

Claim Review:Claim: The video shows a shoe thrown at BJP leader and Union minister Mansukh Mandaviya ahead of the Lok Sabha election.
Claimed By:X and Facebook users
Claim Reviewed By:NewsMeter
Claim Source:X and Facebook
Claim Fact Check:Misleading
Fact:The video shows shoes hurled at Mansukh Mandaviya but from 2017. The incident happened during a public function in Vallabhipur town in Gujaratā€™s Bhavnagar district.
Next Story